3 Things People Tell You about Writing that are Wrong

Assiduously avoiding grading my pile of midterms, I instead wander the stacks of my local bookstore like some demented sprite. And while browsing my local Barnes and Noble, I have discovered that approximately 7.39 billion writers have written books on how to write. They probably all give excellent advice. But in the “writing advice for aspiring authors” category, I keep seeing some things that are just—weird. And like tofurkey, they can’t possibly be right. Here are the three rules for writing that are just bizarrely wrong.

  1. If you want to write, read great authors.

Oh! Shots fired. All right, all right. Let the squealing as of the gates of Hades torn asunder and all the devils let loose commence. The Gospel of Writing 101, the Holiest of Creeds, the One True Thing of all writing is that good writers read great writers. Everyone knows this.

Look, I’m not ever going to say that you shouldn’t read great books. Everyone should read great books. But reading a great book doesn’t make you a great writer. And sure, okay, maybe reading great books helps you hone your craft or get inspired—those are very nice things and will come in handy when you’re thinking about beginning to maybe one day write a novel or when you are polishing your manuscript for submission to an agent who’s shown interest. The whole distance in between those two things is going to go a lot better if you have something to write about.

Great writers fly planes or wait tables. Great writers survive giving birth or get lost in a casbah in Morocco. Great writers shoot a rattlesnake in the head after a dinner out with the wife. I don’t know if I want to read the magnum opus of a good writer locked in a room with a computer and a shelf full of the greatest books ever written. But I do want to read the magnum opus of a good writer who shot a rattlesnake in the head.

I mean, you should be reading the great books anyway, just on principle. If you never read anything longer than your Chipotle cup, you’re probably a terrible person.

But if you want to write, go live something worth writing about.

  1. Don’t let rejection get you down; keep revising, keep re-submitting.

True story: lazy writers don’t get published. Well, I mean, E. L. James got published. So there’s that. But more to the point, part of this sage wisdom is solid. Good writers are great revisers.

One of my favorite authors, James Salter, wrote a brilliant little masterpiece called Cassada, which is in fact a completely rewritten—as in, start-to-finish rewritten—version of an earlier, failed novel. In between failing to write Cassada and writing it, he wrote a great deal of other magnificent pieces. Here’s the thing: failing to write Cassada the first time around was how Salter wrote his best work.

And writers get rejected, that’s true enough. But sometimes the best thing to do is take that rejection and internalize it, and just throw the rejected piece away. Delete a whole manuscript. Take the last extant copy of your masterpiece that got rejected seven times, soak it in the cheapest vodka you own, and light a match. If you need to rewrite it, you will—one day, once you’re a better writer and you figure out how to rewrite it. But chances are, you needed to write that piece of shit novel so that you can get rid of that shit novel so that you can go write your real masterpiece. Sometimes rejection is the right answer.

  1. Treat your writing like your day job.

I guess this one depends on how much you love your day job. If your day job is being Hugh Hefner then sure, treat your writing like your day job. If your day job involves showing up at 8:02.58 because if you log in at 8:03 you’re late, and if your day job involves sitting in a cubicle for the next eight hours and if you spend 83% of your workday looking at fat three-toed sloth babies on Buzzfeed, why the hell would it be good advice to take the one thing you love more than anything—writing—and treat it like your day job?

What people mean when they say this, I assume, is that if you want to write, you have to actually park yourself in a chair and write, and not just waft around telling people about that novel you’re one day going to publish. I don’t know. That seems like weird advice to me. Sure, there are some people who say they want to write, they just never find the time. There are some people who want to waft around talking about a novel they might or might not one day write. Let them.

Most writers are people who write because they are writers—in the same way that some people pitch baseballs with their left hands because they’re left-handed. Most writers write because they have to. Because it’s in them like some parasitic creature clinging to the inside of their ribcage or hunkered inside their skull. Because they can’t help it. Should you schedule writing? If you want to. Sure. Go for it. But, I mean, come on. If you hate your day job and writing is your passion? Then leave the clock punching for the day job and break out the gin and the jazz and the joy when you write.

And now, if you’ll excuse me, there’s a Tanqueray with my name on it and a blank document that won’t scribble itself.


One thought on “3 Things People Tell You about Writing that are Wrong

  1. “Well, I mean, E. L. James got published. So there’s that.”
    Not entirely sure I agree with “live something worth writing about,” though. Granted, that too is good general advice anyway–people who have ~artistic pretentions and never *do* anything are boring people and will probably write boring, pretentious “literary fiction” and never understand why the Great Unwashed can’t appreciate their greatness. That said, life experience doesn’t necessarily figure into a book that’s outside one’s own experience. (This is my quibble with “write what you know,” too.) I write historical fiction, for example, and one of my main characters is blind. Can’t say as I have personal experience being a blind man in the 1870s! But there are such things as imagination and research.
    Then again, my version of that bit of advice is, “If you want to be a good writer, you need to be a good reader,” which is not necessarily the same as reading the greats… because sometimes the “lowbrow” stuff is a more relevant model, and sometimes you need to know what *not* to do!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s